Skip to content
DeltaLogic

Neither Saint Nor Sinner: The Baroque Master’s Dynamic Portrait of Magdalene.

One woman leans her head back. Her eyes are shut, her mouth is closed, yet she is awake and aware. With warm cheeks and red lips, her lustrous honey-colored hair catches the glow from a nearby candle, casting a luminous glow in an predominantly shadowy space. She wears ranges from a lace-trimmed blouse—falling off one shoulder to reveal porcelain skin—to a rich ochre and amethyst cloth. Seemingly by herself, oblivious of any onlooker, existing in a state of sublime autonomy.

A Significant New Purchase

The woman is Mary Magdalene “in ecstasy”, crafted in the early 1620s by the renowned painter Artemisia. Freshly purchased by the National Gallery of Art in the U.S. capital, it is scheduled to go on exhibition from late February. It is the gallery’s maiden purchase of a work by the artist, and expert a leading scholar has written that it depicts the saint as “free from remorse and pain”. This is an crucial distinction, for ages, her representation has been shaped not just by scripture but fabulated and blurred by powerful men.

“The most adaptable woman in religious painting,” according to a expert has noted.

Study renderings of her and you will see a thinker, orator, disciple, and observer; weeping at the base of the crucifix, washing Christ’s feet, or looking heavenward—often repenting with shimmering tears and, too often, revealing her chest. At times identified by a ointment vessel or a crimson garment—unlike the Madonna’s blue—she is most popularly regarded today as Christ’s lover, even though no biblical account labeling her as such.

Deciphering the True Identity

“Honestly, we cannot be certain who she was,” noted the scholar. “So all these layers of meaning have fallen upon her. The shifts she undergoes, not just in art but in story, devotionally, in doctrine, are as closely tied to societal views and theological shifts as they are to faith.” What then do we know?

She is mentioned in the New Testament 12 times. Initially, she has seven “demons” cast out from her; subsequently, she is seen at the crucifixion and is the first person to experience his rising. She is the one who spreads the “good news”. Her sexual and sinful legacy can largely be traced to a homily given in the late sixth century by Gregory I, who confused her with Mary of Bethany and an anonymous sinner who washed Jesus’s feet with her tears.

By collapsing them together, he effectively “invented” the penitent prostitute—a myth further elaborated by subsequent church fathers and medieval legends. Artists followed suit, and in a largely illiterate but image-savvy world, this was highly impactful. Her “evil spirits” morphed into the “cardinal vices”, establishing her dominant narrative as one of sexual fall and subsequent redemption—concretised in artistic renderings that still shape perceptions today.

Centuries of Penitence and Objectification

From the sculptor’s emaciated, wooden figure clasping her hands in penitence, to Caravaggio’s seventeenth-century depiction of her devoid of life and near death—alongside Rubens’ semi-nude, rapturous saint held aloft by angels. Her image has frequently been diminished sexually. One artist’s print presented her demurely, with flowing hair covering her unclothed body, while another’s version looks heavenward, with tearful eyes and strategically placed hands revealing her breasts.

Evidently, anguish and objectification were the dominant poles in her representation: she could act as a cautionary tale against transgression, be the exemplar for repentance, while offering artists a pretext to depict semi-nudity masked as devotion. This “fallen woman redeemed” trope endured for centuries—so deeply that institutions known as “Magdalene asylums” subjected women into exploitative labor, systems that astonishingly only closed just thirty years ago.

A Radical Reimagining

However, consider if there was another side to her story? What if her tale could be one of enlightenment and transformation, where she was shown as vibrant, joy, and sublimity? Essentially, what if we viewed her through the lens of a woman?

This is what Gentileschi achieves. Her Magdalene is not performing for the audience; she is without tears, not penitent, without shame, not objectified, and not dictating a moral lesson. Instead, she has rosy cheeks and is, according to notes, “vibrantly living … in the throes of divine joy”. One curator remarked that Gentileschi “imbues Mary Magdalene with an electrifying life force”.

“Yes, it’s an rapture painting, but it’s not her moment of conversion. It’s a moment of divine meeting … spoken of at times as if it’s the finest physical experience … the most profound orgasm she could ever have. It’s beautiful, it’s bodily, it’s sensual, it’s transcendent. You are lifted beyond oneself to a higher level.”

Often, when female artists portray scriptural or mythological women, they show them not as submissive, sinful, ashamed, or subordinate, but as agentic, multifaceted, and with wills of their own: “Females with a capital ‘Woman’”.

A Greater Shift Towards Equality

Thus, while this new Gentileschi may ultimately be redressing a gender imbalance at the gallery, its significance extends further. It changes not just how we perceive religious and mythological women, but also the female experience at large.

This perspective is one the Church eventually acknowledged. In the late 1960s, it formally affirmed her canonical definition as a faithful follower rather than a penitent sinner. More recently 2016, Pope Francis elevated her status to “the apostle of apostles”, marking 22 July as her celebration. It seems that, while establishments evolve, viewpoints are transforming. This new purchase—of a woman free from a patriarchal gaze, living for herself, not suffering and not exploited—is a component in a greater movement towards a more balanced representation.

About the author

Bailey Reed

A technology strategist with over 15 years of experience in IT consulting and digital transformation projects across various industries.

DeltaLogic

Type to search articles.